Fifteen-plus years of BC mortgage experience, distilled into practical writing on buying, renewing, refinancing, and building wealth through real estate.
TD Securities: Markets Are Wrong About Fed Rate Holds, and the Dollar Will Pay
The Federal Reserve will almost certainly hold rates steady on Wednesday. Futures markets put the probability above 95%. But TD Securities argues that same consensus has backed itself into a corner it doesn't realize yet.
The issue isn't whether the Fed holds. It's what the hold signals. Right now, the dollar is trading near the top of its 52-week range because markets have priced in something closer to "higher for longer" than to "we're done here." The gap between those two interpretations is wider than the DXY index suggests, and TD thinks the Fed's language will resolve it the wrong way for dollar bulls.
The mispricing isn't about the decision
Markets already know rates are staying at 5.25%, 5.50%. What they haven't agreed on is whether that's a pause before another hike or the end of the cycle. TD's view: the Fed is closer to cutting than hiking, and the market is holding the dollar as if the opposite were true.
The evidence sits in the bond market. The 2-year Treasury yield has been sticky, holding a wide spread over Canadian government bonds, which keeps capital flowing into USD-denominated assets. That spread exists because traders still see upside risk to the Fed's terminal rate, a 5.75% or 6.00% scenario isn't fully off the table in current pricing. If the Fed closes that door, even implicitly, the yield advantage narrows and the dollar loses its gravitational pull.
TD's base case is what they're calling a "dovish hold." The FOMC keeps rates flat but softens the forward guidance, opening the door to cuts in Q4 2026 if inflation continues to cool. Core PCE inflation has been decelerating for three consecutive months. The Fed hasn't acknowledged that momentum yet in a way that moves expectations. If they do, the dollar sells off.
What that means for the loonie
A weaker USD doesn't automatically mean a stronger Canadian dollar, but it creates the conditions. The USD/CAD exchange rate is unusually sensitive to the U.S.-Canada rate differential right now because both central banks are near the same inflection point. If the Fed signals it's done tightening while the Bank of Canada holds firm, the loonie gets a bid.
For Canadian mortgage holders, that matters less directly than BoC policy does, but a stronger CAD gives the Bank of Canada more room to maneuver. Imported inflation becomes less of a constraint. The BoC has been reluctant to cut while the loonie is weak because it risks re-igniting price growth through the import channel. A firmer currency changes that calculation, even at the margin.
The counterargument is that the dollar might rally even on a dovish hold if the dovishness comes from growth weakness rather than inflation progress. The "dollar smile" theory says USD strengthens in both boom times and crash times, weakening only in the middle. If the Fed is pausing because the economy is rolling over, safe-haven flows could offset any yield-driven selling.
TD acknowledges this but argues the current setup doesn't support it. Employment is cooling but not collapsing. Retail sales are flat but not falling. The kind of recession panic that drives safe-haven dollar demand isn't present in the August data. The more likely scenario is a Fed that's satisfied inflation is under control and willing to say so, which removes the hawkish tail risk the dollar has been trading on.
The timing matters. The dollar's rally from mid-2025 to now has been built on the idea that U.S. rates would stay elevated longer than the rest of the developed world's. Every month that passes with inflation behaving pushes the Fed closer to the exit. Markets are still pricing for the old regime. TD thinks Wednesday is when that changes.
The Federal Reserve will almost certainly hold rates steady on Wednesday. Futures markets put the probability above 95%. But TD Securities argues that same consensus has backed itself into a corner it doesn't realize yet.
The issue isn't whether the Fed holds. It's what the hold signals. Right now, the dollar is trading near the top of its 52-week range because markets have priced in something closer to "higher for longer" than to "we're done here." The gap between those two interpretations is wider than the DXY index suggests, and TD thinks the Fed's language will resolve it the wrong way for dollar bulls.
The mispricing isn't about the decision
Markets already know rates are staying at 5.25%, 5.50%. What they haven't agreed on is whether that's a pause before another hike or the end of the cycle. TD's view: the Fed is closer to cutting than hiking, and the market is holding the dollar as if the opposite were true.
The evidence sits in the bond market. The 2-year Treasury yield has been sticky, holding a wide spread over Canadian government bonds, which keeps capital flowing into USD-denominated assets. That spread exists because traders still see upside risk to the Fed's terminal rate, a 5.75% or 6.00% scenario isn't fully off the table in current pricing. If the Fed closes that door, even implicitly, the yield advantage narrows and the dollar loses its gravitational pull.
TD's base case is what they're calling a "dovish hold." The FOMC keeps rates flat but softens the forward guidance, opening the door to cuts in Q4 2026 if inflation continues to cool. Core PCE inflation has been decelerating for three consecutive months. The Fed hasn't acknowledged that momentum yet in a way that moves expectations. If they do, the dollar sells off.
What that means for the loonie
A weaker USD doesn't automatically mean a stronger Canadian dollar, but it creates the conditions. The USD/CAD exchange rate is unusually sensitive to the U.S.-Canada rate differential right now because both central banks are near the same inflection point. If the Fed signals it's done tightening while the Bank of Canada holds firm, the loonie gets a bid.
For Canadian mortgage holders, that matters less directly than BoC policy does, but a stronger CAD gives the Bank of Canada more room to maneuver. Imported inflation becomes less of a constraint. The BoC has been reluctant to cut while the loonie is weak because it risks re-igniting price growth through the import channel. A firmer currency changes that calculation, even at the margin.
The counterargument is that the dollar might rally even on a dovish hold if the dovishness comes from growth weakness rather than inflation progress. The "dollar smile" theory says USD strengthens in both boom times and crash times, weakening only in the middle. If the Fed is pausing because the economy is rolling over, safe-haven flows could offset any yield-driven selling.
TD acknowledges this but argues the current setup doesn't support it. Employment is cooling but not collapsing. Retail sales are flat but not falling. The kind of recession panic that drives safe-haven dollar demand isn't present in the August data. The more likely scenario is a Fed that's satisfied inflation is under control and willing to say so, which removes the hawkish tail risk the dollar has been trading on.
The timing matters. The dollar's rally from mid-2025 to now has been built on the idea that U.S. rates would stay elevated longer than the rest of the developed world's. Every month that passes with inflation behaving pushes the Fed closer to the exit. Markets are still pricing for the old regime. TD thinks Wednesday is when that changes.
Read Next
Personal Letters Still Win Toronto Homes When Everyone Else Assumes They Don't
25 States Sue Trump Over Tariffs, Testing the Outer Limits of Executive Trade Power
Carney's Alberta Housing Tour Met by Separatist Flags and Growing Regional Fracture
Kelowna Ranks First in Canada for Wildfire Risk: What Condo Buyers Need to Check Before Closing